El Salvador Bitcoin: Latest News and Updates

Francis Merced
October 30, 2025
3 Views
el salvador bitcoin

A country of 6.5 million people now holds over 5,800 Bitcoin in its treasury. That’s worth hundreds of millions of dollars. This isn’t a tech company or hedge fund—it’s an actual nation betting on digital currency.

I’ve tracked this el salvador bitcoin journey since President Bukele’s historic announcement in September 2021. Reactions varied wildly. Some called it visionary, while others predicted economic collapse.

Today, we have real data to examine. This breakdown covers everything happening with Bitcoin as legal tender in this Central American nation. We’ll explore adoption rates, government holdings, what’s working on the ground, and what this means globally.

Key Takeaways

  • El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender in September 2021, launching a unprecedented monetary experiment
  • The government has accumulated over 5,800 Bitcoin through strategic purchases and mining operations
  • Adoption rates among citizens remain mixed, with younger populations showing higher engagement
  • Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte serves as the grassroots origin point that inspired national adoption
  • International financial institutions initially criticized the move but are now watching closely for results
  • The country’s Bitcoin holdings have experienced significant volatility, affecting national treasury values
  • Tourism and international attention have increased substantially since the Bitcoin law implementation

Overview of Bitcoin in El Salvador

The story of bitcoin adoption in el salvador starts with a tweet and a bold president. This decision sent shockwaves through the global financial system. A Miami tech conference announcement transformed into one of the most controversial financial experiments ever.

I’ve been following this story since day one. It still feels surreal that a small Central American nation bet its economic future on cryptocurrency. El Salvador didn’t just dip its toes into digital currency – it cannonballed straight in.

Understanding what happened requires looking at both the how and the why behind this move.

Making History with Digital Currency

President Nayib Bukele dropped the bombshell announcement at the Bitcoin 2021 Conference in Miami. This happened on June 5, 2021. Within days, the Legislative Assembly moved with surprising speed.

On June 9, 2021, they passed the Bitcoin Law with 62 out of 84 votes. This decisive majority made el salvador bitcoin legal tender alongside the US dollar.

The law itself was surprisingly straightforward. Every business with the technological capability had to accept Bitcoin for goods and services. No exceptions existed for companies that could process digital payments.

Here’s what made it workable for skeptical businesses. The government established a $150 million trust fund through the Development Bank of El Salvador. This fund backed instant Bitcoin-to-dollar conversions, eliminating exchange rate risk for merchants.

The official implementation date landed on September 7, 2021. That’s when bitcoin adoption in el salvador moved from theory to practice. The government rolled out Chivo Wallet, a state-sponsored digital wallet.

Citizens received a $30 Bitcoin bonus just for signing up. Over 200 Bitcoin ATMs appeared across the country practically overnight.

When the World Took Notice

The international response was mixed, to put it diplomatically. The International Monetary Fund immediately raised red flags about financial stability and consumer protection. They had valid concerns about volatility and the rushed implementation timeline.

The World Bank’s response was even more pointed. They flat-out declined to assist with the el salvador bitcoin legal tender rollout. Their reasoning centered on environmental concerns and transparency issues.

Meanwhile, the cryptocurrency community went absolutely wild with enthusiasm. Bitcoin maximalists saw this as vindication. Finally, a real-world test of Bitcoin as actual money existed.

Local reactions painted a more complicated picture:

  • Younger Salvadorans generally embraced the technology, especially those already working in remittances or tech sectors
  • Traditional business owners expressed frustration about mandatory adoption without adequate training
  • Street vendors complained about needing smartphones and reliable internet just to sell pupusas
  • Opposition groups organized protests in San Salvador, burning Bitcoin ATMs and demanding the law’s repeal

The concerns weren’t just about technology. Many Salvadorans worried about price volatility. Imagine pricing your groceries in a currency that could swing 10% in a single day.

What struck me most was the mandatory nature of the rollout. This wasn’t a gradual adoption or voluntary pilot program. The government essentially said “we’re doing this, get on board.”

International credit rating agencies also weighed in. Moody’s and Fitch both expressed concerns about fiscal risks. These weren’t just theoretical worries – they had real implications for borrowing costs.

Current Bitcoin Adoption Statistics in El Salvador

Tracking Bitcoin adoption statistics in El Salvador reveals a surprising gap. Official claims often differ from what’s happening on the ground. Getting accurate data means digging past surface-level metrics.

Measuring bitcoin adoption in el salvador requires separating enthusiasm from execution. Initial reports painted an optimistic picture. Reality involves more complexity than headlines suggest.

Number of Bitcoin Wallet Users

The government launched the chivo wallet in September 2021 with significant fanfare. Every citizen who downloaded and registered received a $30 Bitcoin bonus. Official reports claimed over 4 million downloads within the first few months.

That number sounds impressive for a country of 6.5 million people. But downloads don’t equal active users. That distinction matters tremendously.

Independent surveys from 2022 to 2024 reveal a more modest reality. A 2023 National Bureau of Economic Research study made an important finding. Approximately 20% of users continued using the chivo wallet after spending their initial bonus.

Most Salvadorans downloaded the app and claimed their free Bitcoin. Then they abandoned regular usage.

Current estimates suggest regular Bitcoin wallet users represent 10-20% of the population. That translates to roughly 650,000 to 1.3 million active users. This remains significant but considerably less than initial projections.

Recent Transaction Volumes

Transaction volumes provide another lens for understanding actual Bitcoin usage. The Central Reserve Bank doesn’t release comprehensive transaction data regularly. This makes independent analysis challenging and sometimes frustrating.

Bitcoin transactions represent less than 5% of total financial transactions in El Salvador. The majority of economic activity flows through traditional banking channels. Cash payments still dominate daily commerce.

That 5% figure has remained relatively stable since late 2022. The most significant Bitcoin activity concentrates in one specific area: remittances. Salvadorans living abroad send approximately $7 billion home annually.

This represents about 24% of the country’s GDP. Bitcoin offers real advantages here by reducing fees significantly. Traditional services charge 7-10% while Bitcoin costs under 2%.

Remittance-related transactions account for an estimated 60-70% of all Bitcoin activity. This makes economic sense for families sending money home. Saving $50-$80 on every $1,000 transferred adds up quickly.

Bitcoin’s Impact on Local Economy

Measuring Bitcoin’s economic impact requires looking at direct savings and broader effects. The numbers tell a story of modest but measurable benefits. Some genuine concerns exist alongside these advantages.

El Salvador saved an estimated $400 million in remittance fees during the first two years. That money stayed in Salvadoran pockets instead of going to traditional services. For families receiving remittances, this represents meaningful financial relief.

Tourism to Bitcoin-focused areas experienced noticeable growth. El Zonte, known as Bitcoin Beach, saw increased visitor numbers. Hotels, restaurants, and surf shops began accepting Bitcoin.

Adoption Metric 2021 Launch 2023 Data Economic Impact
Chivo Wallet Downloads 4+ million 4.2 million Initial engagement high
Active User Percentage 60% estimated 10-20% actual Lower than projected
Bitcoin Transaction Share 15% projected Less than 5% Limited daily use
Remittance Fee Savings Not applicable $400 million total Significant family benefit

However, volatility presents a serious counterbalance to these benefits. Bitcoin crashed in 2022, and the government’s holdings lost substantial value. The treasury purchased Bitcoin at various price points.

The subsequent price drop raised legitimate concerns about fiscal responsibility. Small businesses accepting Bitcoin face similar challenges. A shopkeeper might accept payment at $40,000 only to see value drop.

This volatility risk makes many merchants hesitant despite the technology’s potential. The broader economic transformation some advocates predicted hasn’t materialized yet. Bitcoin functions primarily as a remittance tool rather than comprehensive currency replacement.

Most Salvadorans still prefer dollars for daily transactions. They use traditional currency for savings and business operations.

Government Initiatives Supporting Bitcoin Use

President Bukele knew legal recognition was just the starting point for national transformation. The government had to build actual infrastructure and create educational resources. They established regulatory frameworks to make adoption possible rather than just permissible.

The approach was comprehensive, even if execution hasn’t been perfect. Real money and planning backed the nayib bukele bitcoin initiative. Transparency around exact spending has been frustratingly limited.

Investment in Bitcoin Infrastructure

The most visible government investment came through Bitcoin ATMs scattered across the country. El Salvador installed over 200 Chivo ATMs nationwide within the first year. That’s a remarkable density for a small country.

These weren’t just placed in San Salvador. The government strategically distributed them across urban centers and rural areas. This made El Salvador one of the most crypto-ATM-dense nations globally.

Hardware was only part of the infrastructure challenge. Digital currency requires reliable internet access, which was spotty in rural regions. The government invested in upgrading connectivity infrastructure and expanding internet availability.

Total infrastructure investment exceeded $200 million in the first two years. That figure includes ATM installation, internet improvements, and wallet development. The exact breakdown remains unclear because detailed cost accounting wasn’t released.

Here’s what we know about the major infrastructure components:

  • Over 200 Chivo Bitcoin ATMs installed nationwide
  • Government-developed Chivo Wallet distributed to citizens
  • $30 initial Bitcoin bonus provided to wallet users
  • Expanded fiber optic networks in rural regions
  • Payment processing systems for merchants

The infrastructure isn’t perfect. ATMs have experienced technical problems, and wallet functionality has been glitchy. But the scale of investment demonstrates genuine commitment beyond symbolic gestures.

Educational Programs on Cryptocurrency

Infrastructure means nothing if people don’t understand how to use it. The government recognized this reality and invested in cryptocurrency education. They partnered with various organizations to provide training and resources.

The centerpiece was establishing a Bitcoin Education Center for citizens. People could learn about digital wallets, security practices, and basic blockchain concepts. The focus was practical application, not abstract theory.

The el salvador crypto law implementation included educational curriculum materials distributed to schools. Students received lessons on digital finance, cryptocurrency basics, and economic rationale. This represents a comprehensive approach to long-term adoption.

Adoption of these educational programs has been extremely uneven. Urban residents with existing technological literacy embraced them more readily. Rural populations dealing primarily in cash showed less interest and participation.

The government created legal frameworks extending beyond the initial legislation. They established regulations for Bitcoin businesses and licensing requirements for exchanges. Consumer protection guidelines were also developed.

The crypto law includes a significant incentive. It exempts Bitcoin profits from capital gains taxes. This tax exemption makes El Salvador attractive for crypto businesses and investors.

Some major cryptocurrency companies explored establishing operations there. Fewer have actually followed through than the government initially anticipated. This gap reveals the complexity of building a crypto-friendly business environment.

The nayib bukele bitcoin strategy included regulatory clarity that many nations lack. El Salvador defined clear rules for crypto exchanges and established anti-money laundering requirements. This framework attempts to balance innovation with consumer protection.

Key Bitcoin Projects in El Salvador

El Salvador isn’t just implementing Bitcoin wallets and transactions. They’re planning entire cities and revolutionary financial instruments. These ambitious projects represent President Bukele’s vision for transforming the country into a global cryptocurrency hub.

The scale is massive, and the timelines are uncertain. The outcomes could reshape how nations think about digital currency infrastructure.

I’ve been following these developments closely, and they’re equal parts inspiring and nerve-wracking. The gap between announcement and execution tells its own story. It shows the challenges of implementing groundbreaking technology at a national scale.

Bitcoin Bond Initiative

The Volcano Bonds represent one of the most innovative financing mechanisms in cryptocurrency history. Announced in November 2021, this initiative proposed raising $1 billion through bond issuance backed partially by Bitcoin holdings. The structure was elegant: use half the proceeds to expand salvadoran bitcoin reserves.

The other half would build energy infrastructure and mining operations. Investors would benefit from two revenue streams.

First, potential Bitcoin appreciation as the cryptocurrency’s value increased over time. Second, profits from geothermal energy production that would power massive mining facilities.

The bonds carried a 6.5% annual yield with a 10-year maturity period. This made them attractive compared to traditional sovereign debt. The cryptocurrency component added upside potential.

Here’s where theory met reality. The bonds were scheduled to launch in March 2022, but that deadline came and went. Market volatility hit hard as Bitcoin prices dropped from their 2021 highs.

Investor confidence wavered, and regulatory concerns from international financial institutions added complications.

Throughout 2023 and into 2024, the government continued negotiations with potential investors. They’ve discussed modified versions of the original proposal. Terms were adjusted to reflect current market realities.

But as of late 2024, the Volcano Bonds haven’t materialized in any form close to the original vision.

The delays raise important questions about crypto-backed sovereign debt instruments. Can they work at scale? Do investors trust government cryptocurrency management?

The answers matter because this project could become a blueprint for other nations. Or it could be a cautionary tale about overambitious planning.

Development of a Bitcoin City

If Volcano Bonds sound ambitious, the el salvador bitcoin city concept takes things to another level entirely. President Bukele unveiled plans in November 2021 for a futuristic city built from scratch. The location would be in the La Unión department on the country’s eastern coast.

This wouldn’t be a small tech campus. We’re talking about a complete municipality designed around Bitcoin and cryptocurrency innovation.

The location choice wasn’t random. La Unión sits near the Conchagua volcano, which would provide geothermal energy to power the entire city. It would also power massive Bitcoin mining operations.

Renewable energy makes the project theoretically sustainable. It addresses one of cryptocurrency’s biggest criticisms: environmental impact.

The tax structure designed for el salvador bitcoin city is incredibly aggressive. Residents and businesses would pay zero income tax, zero property tax, and zero capital gains tax. The only levy? A 10% value-added tax on goods and services.

This creates a potential tax haven specifically for cryptocurrency businesses and investors.

Architectural renderings showed a circular city layout with a central plaza featuring a giant Bitcoin symbol. The design included residential neighborhoods, commercial districts, entertainment zones, and industrial areas for mining operations. Everything would accept Bitcoin as the primary currency.

This would create a real-world testing ground for a cryptocurrency-based economy.

Funding for this massive undertaking would come from those Volcano Bonds. The projected cost ran into billions of dollars. It would require sustained investment over many years.

The timeline suggested initial infrastructure by 2024. Full development would stretch into the late 2020s.

Now for the reality check. As of 2024, the el salvador bitcoin city remains largely conceptual. Some preliminary work has occurred: land surveys, environmental studies, and infrastructure planning.

But there’s no actual city construction happening. No buildings, no residents, no functioning Bitcoin metropolis.

The same factors delaying Volcano Bonds have stalled Bitcoin City. Without bond funding, the project lacks capital. Market volatility makes long-term planning difficult.

Questions persist about whether the economics actually work. Can a city function primarily on cryptocurrency? Will businesses relocate there?

Will people actually want to live in a planned crypto community?

I’m watching this project with cautious curiosity because the implications are enormous. If Bitcoin City succeeds, it proves cryptocurrency can support physical infrastructure at scale. It demonstrates that digital assets can anchor real economic development.

Other nations might follow El Salvador’s lead, creating competing cryptocurrency zones.

If it fails, it becomes a symbol of crypto hype exceeding practical implementation. Critics would point to it as evidence that Bitcoin speculation doesn’t translate to sustainable economic development. The reputational damage could set back cryptocurrency adoption globally.

The connection between these projects is crucial. Volcano Bonds fund Bitcoin City. Bitcoin City justifies Volcano Bonds.

Without one, the other struggles to make sense. This interdependence means both initiatives need to succeed together, or they’ll likely fail together.

What strikes me most is the boldness of attempting both simultaneously. Rather than testing one concept before launching another, El Salvador committed to a comprehensive Bitcoin infrastructure vision. That’s either brilliant strategic thinking or risky overextension.

We won’t know which until more time passes.

Challenges Facing Bitcoin Adoption

The Bitcoin Law created legal frameworks for cryptocurrency use. However, practical challenges have emerged that affect everyday Salvadorans. These obstacles range from economic uncertainties to technical barriers that government initiatives haven’t fully resolved.

Let me walk you through the reality of what’s actually slowing down bitcoin adoption in el salvador.

Price Volatility Creates Real Financial Risk

Bitcoin’s price swings remain the biggest concern for anyone considering regular cryptocurrency use. El Salvador’s Bitcoin Law passed in June 2021 with BTC trading around $45,000. By implementation day in September, it had climbed to $52,000.

Then came the brutal crash. By November 2022, Bitcoin had plummeted to just $16,000.

Imagine you’re running a small restaurant in San Salvador. You accept Bitcoin payment for a $1,000 catering order when BTC sits at $50,000. Two weeks later, you need to pay your food suppliers, but Bitcoin has dropped to $30,000.

That’s a $400 real loss affecting your ability to restock.

The government hasn’t been immune to these swings either. El Salvador’s Bitcoin holdings have lost tens of millions during market downturns. Critics argue this puts taxpayer money at unnecessary risk during economic uncertainty.

Survey data from the Central American University in 2023 showed that 75% of Salvadorans who tried Bitcoin cited volatility as their primary concern for not continuing to use it regularly.

This volatility concern isn’t just theoretical. It’s the number one barrier preventing wider bitcoin adoption in el salvador. Small businesses operating on thin margins simply can’t afford to gamble on currency fluctuations.

Many who initially experimented with accepting crypto have quietly returned to dollar-only transactions.

Technical Infrastructure Gaps Limit Accessibility

Beyond economic concerns, technical barriers create daily friction that government education programs haven’t overcome. Internet penetration in El Salvador sits around 60%. This means 40% of the population lacks reliable internet access necessary for digital currency transactions.

You can’t process a Bitcoin payment without connectivity.

Power outages remain common in rural areas. I’ve talked to business owners who’ve experienced this frustration firsthand. Customers are ready to pay with Bitcoin, but the electricity’s out.

No power means no transaction. Customers often don’t have cash alternatives.

The Chivo wallet itself has experienced significant technical problems that undermine confidence:

  • Transaction failures during peak usage periods
  • Long confirmation times when the Bitcoin network experiences congestion
  • Security vulnerabilities that resulted in some users losing funds
  • App crashes requiring reinstallation and recovery processes

Smartphone ownership creates another hurdle. Urban Salvadorans increasingly own smartphones. However, many rural residents still use basic phones incapable of running cryptocurrency wallets.

According to infrastructure assessments, approximately 35% of Salvadorans lack smartphones that can handle Bitcoin applications.

Digital literacy presents perhaps the steepest challenge. Understanding private keys, wallet addresses, and blockchain confirmations requires education that hasn’t reached everyone. The learning curve is steeper than government officials initially anticipated.

Even motivated users struggle with concepts like:

  1. Securing and backing up private keys without losing access to funds
  2. Distinguishing between different cryptocurrency networks and tokens
  3. Understanding transaction fees and optimal timing for transfers
  4. Recognizing phishing attempts and security threats

These technical infrastructure issues affect bitcoin adoption in el salvador more than any marketing campaign can overcome. Until internet access becomes universal, power supply stabilizes, and digital literacy improves, cryptocurrency will remain inaccessible. The government has acknowledged these challenges but hasn’t yet implemented comprehensive solutions.

Public Sentiment towards Bitcoin

The real story of Bitcoin adoption in El Salvador lives in everyday experiences of citizens and business owners. After three years of Bitcoin as legal tender, public opinion has settled into complex patterns. The data shows a population navigating practical realities rather than ideological positions.

Understanding these attitudes matters because they signal whether Bitcoin will genuinely integrate into daily economic life. The patterns emerging now will likely influence cryptocurrency market cycles and adoption strategies in other nations. El Salvador’s experiment offers valuable lessons for the future.

Survey Data Reveals Mixed Acceptance Patterns

Universidad Centroamericana has conducted the most comprehensive polling on Bitcoin sentiment since 2021. Their 2023 survey reveals numbers that challenge both optimistic and pessimistic narratives. Approximately 12% of Salvadorans actively use Bitcoin regularly, with another 20% having tried it occasionally.

Awareness has grown substantially. Roughly 77% of respondents now understand what Bitcoin is. This marks a dramatic increase from pre-2021 levels when cryptocurrency awareness barely registered in national surveys.

Only 35% of Salvadorans view Bitcoin adoption positively. Meanwhile, 45% express skepticism or outright opposition, and 20% remain neutral or uncertain. These numbers suggest neither overwhelming success nor complete rejection.

The generational and geographic divides tell the more interesting story. Young urban Salvadorans aged 18-35 show 48% favorability toward Bitcoin. Rural residents over 50 show only 18% favorability. This split makes practical sense considering differences in smartphone access, internet reliability, and financial needs.

Demographic Group Bitcoin Favorability Active Usage Rate Primary Concern
Urban Youth (18-35) 48% 23% Learning curve
Urban Adults (36-50) 32% 11% Volatility
Rural Residents (50+) 18% 4% Technical access
National Average 35% 12% Multiple factors

The chivo wallet government app has been downloaded millions of times. The initial $30 Bitcoin bonus partly incentivized these downloads. But download numbers don’t reflect sustained usage—many Salvadorans tried the wallet, collected the bonus, and converted it immediately.

Business Owner Experiences Vary Dramatically by Location

Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte represents what successful adoption could look like under ideal conditions. This small coastal community started accepting Bitcoin in 2019, two years before the national law. An anonymous Bitcoin donor funded the project to create a real-world testing ground.

Walking through bitcoin beach el salvador today reveals restaurants, hostels, surf shops, and local businesses genuinely operating on Bitcoin. Residents received targeted education in cryptocurrency use. The community built supporting infrastructure, and tourism increased significantly, bringing economic benefits that reinforced positive attitudes.

But El Zonte had advantages that don’t scale easily to a nation of 6.5 million people. Concentrated resources, focused education programs, and a relatively small population created conditions for success. The question has always been whether this model could expand beyond a showcase community.

Business perspectives across the broader country tell a different story. A 2023 survey of small business owners found that 60% had stopped accepting Bitcoin after initially trying it. Their reasons cluster around practical concerns that make daily operations challenging.

  • Transaction complexity compared to cash or traditional card payments
  • Accounting difficulties for tax purposes when dealing with volatile assets
  • Customer preference for dollars or chivo wallet conversions rather than holding Bitcoin
  • Technical support gaps when payment systems encounter problems

Large businesses with existing payment infrastructure adapted more easily. Hotels, major retailers, and chains treat Bitcoin as just another payment option. They absorb volatility through immediate conversion to dollars. Small businesses lack this buffer and feel the risk more acutely.

Businesses in tourist areas continue accepting Bitcoin more consistently. Tourists specifically seek out places where they can spend cryptocurrency. This creates economic incentive that outweighs the operational complexity.

These businesses essentially serve two different markets. They accommodate locals who prefer dollars and visitors who want the Bitcoin experience. This dual approach helps maintain Bitcoin acceptance despite operational challenges.

The sentiment data suggests Bitcoin in El Salvador has found niche adoption rather than wholesale transformation. Young, urban, tech-comfortable Salvadorans use it. Tourist-dependent businesses accept it. Communities like Bitcoin Beach showcase it.

Predictions for Bitcoin’s Future in El Salvador

Nobody knows what happens next with El Salvador Bitcoin. Anyone claiming certainty is probably selling something. The crypto space humbles even confident forecasters.

I treat predictions as educated guesses, not gospel truth. Analyzing current trends gives us reasonable scenarios to consider.

The landscape ahead for El Salvador Bitcoin involves multiple competing forces. Government ambition, economic reality, technological development, and political uncertainty all play roles. Each factor pulls the outcome in different directions.

Economic Forecasts and Bitcoin

Major financial institutions remain skeptical about Bitcoin’s long-term role in El Salvador’s economy. The IMF’s 2024 assessment painted a cautious picture. Cryptocurrency would likely remain a niche payment system rather than displacing the US dollar.

Their projections indicate Bitcoin might stabilize at around 10-15% of total transaction volume. This could happen within five years.

This conservative forecast focuses on remittances and tourism sectors where Bitcoin shows strongest adoption. Traditional financial institutions consistently underestimate Bitcoin’s potential. They also provide important counterbalance to overly optimistic predictions.

Crypto-optimistic analysts paint a dramatically different picture. They predict Bitcoin could enter another bull market reaching $100,000 or higher. El Salvador’s early adoption position could generate substantial returns on government holdings.

These returns might fund infrastructure projects and validate the entire strategy. However, bullish forecasts depend entirely on Bitcoin’s price trajectory. Nobody can reliably predict this.

Bitcoin will likely remain concentrated in specific use cases – remittances, tourism, and as a savings vehicle for tech-savvy citizens – rather than becoming the dominant currency for everyday transactions.

My assessment falls between institutional skepticism and crypto enthusiasm. The USD will probably remain king for most Salvadorans. El salvador bitcoin would occupy an important but secondary role.

Forecast Scenario Bitcoin Transaction Volume Primary Use Cases Timeline
Conservative (IMF/World Bank) 10-15% of total transactions Remittances, limited tourism 5 years
Optimistic (Crypto analysts) 40-50% of total transactions Daily purchases, savings, remittances, tourism 3-5 years
Realistic Middle Ground 20-25% of total transactions Remittances, tourism, tech-savvy savings 5-7 years

Potential for Future Regulations

Regulatory evolution seems inevitable as El Salvador gains experience with cryptocurrency’s practical challenges. The current framework is relatively permissive. Tax evasion potential, money laundering concerns, and consumer protection issues will push government toward more oversight.

We’re already seeing early signs of this shift. KYC requirements for larger transactions have increased. Bitcoin businesses face enhanced oversight.

These changes represent natural maturation rather than hostile regulation.

Future administrations present significant political risk for el salvador bitcoin implementation. Bukele’s term has constitutional limits. His successor might take a completely different approach.

Completely abandoning Bitcoin seems unlikely given international attention and infrastructure investments. Moderation of the most ambitious elements appears probable.

Bitcoin City might be scaled back or reimagined rather than built as originally envisioned. The legal tender status would likely remain. It would exist in a more limited capacity with additional regulatory guardrails protecting consumers.

The international regulatory environment also matters. If major economies adopt hostile cryptocurrency policies, El Salvador might face pressure to align. Conversely, if other nations follow El Salvador’s lead, the experiment gains legitimacy.

The current regulatory approach won’t remain static. As challenges emerge and lessons accumulate, policies will adapt. The question isn’t whether regulations will evolve, but how quickly and in what direction.

El Salvador maintains Bitcoin as legal tender with gradually increasing oversight. Practical usage concentrated in specific sectors. Ambitious projects like Bitcoin City either delayed or significantly modified.

The experiment continues, but expectations moderate toward realistic outcomes rather than revolutionary transformation.

Comparison of Bitcoin and Traditional Currencies

El Salvador’s Bitcoin experiment shows clear differences between crypto and regular money. Real families now use Bitcoin for groceries. Businesses accept it for rent payments.

The comparison reveals surprising truths that challenge both sides. Some advantages are genuine and measurable. Others are more complicated than either side admits.

Benefits of Bitcoin for Consumers

The remittance story stands out as Bitcoin’s most compelling success in El Salvador. Traditional money transfer services extract serious fees from Salvadoran families. They have done this for decades.

Here’s the math that matters. Western Union charges 7-10% in fees. They also hide costs in unfavorable exchange rates.

Bitcoin transactions cut those costs to under 2% in most cases. Remittances represent roughly 24% of GDP in El Salvador. That difference means $400+ million staying in family pockets annually instead of going to intermediaries.

Financial inclusion represents another legitimate advantage I’ve witnessed firsthand. About 70% of Salvadorans lacked traditional banking access before Bitcoin became legal tender.

The barriers were real and frustrating:

  • Minimum balance requirements that excluded low-income families
  • Documentation needs that rural populations couldn’t meet
  • Geographic limitations with no bank branches in remote areas
  • Rejection based on employment status or credit history

Bitcoin wallets require only a smartphone and internet connection. Those are significantly lower barriers than traditional banking demands. This has brought basic financial services to previously excluded populations.

The speed of international transfers also deserves recognition. Traditional wire transfers can take 3-5 business days. Bitcoin transactions settle within minutes to hours, regardless of borders.

Drawbacks vs. Conventional Financial Systems

Volatility makes Bitcoin problematic for everyday purchases and basic necessities. You need price stability for buying groceries or paying rent. A currency losing 20% value in a week creates genuine hardship.

Most Salvadorans solve this by immediately converting Bitcoin to dollars. But that conversion step eliminates some efficiency advantages. It also adds friction back into transactions.

Transaction costs and speeds vary dramatically from marketing claims. During network congestion, Bitcoin transactions can take hours to confirm. Fees can reach $10-30, making small purchases impractical.

The Lightning Network was supposed to fix this problem. It does help, but adds technical complexity. Traditional payment systems remain faster and simpler for routine transactions.

Consumer protection represents perhaps the starkest contrast. The differences affect real people’s financial security:

Protection Feature Traditional Banking Bitcoin System
Fraud disputes Chargeback rights for 60-90 days No reversal mechanism
Lost credentials Password reset with identity verification Lost private keys = permanent fund loss
Unauthorized transactions Bank liability with fraud protection User bears full responsibility
Technical support Customer service and branch assistance Self-custody requires technical knowledge

This reality has resulted in lost funds for less tech-savvy users. They didn’t understand security requirements. I’ve heard stories of people losing substantial amounts because they didn’t secure private keys properly.

Internet dependency creates another practical problem. Traditional cash works during power outages and network failures. Bitcoin requires both electricity and internet access for every transaction.

Internet penetration isn’t universal in El Salvador. Power reliability varies by region. Cash remains the ultimate backup system when technology fails.

The learning curve difference shouldn’t be dismissed either. Everyone understands how cash and bank accounts work. Bitcoin requires understanding private keys, seed phrases, and transaction fees.

Tools and Resources for Bitcoin Users

Understanding available tools helps you avoid frustrating technical headaches in El Salvador. The right setup makes Bitcoin transactions feel almost effortless. I’ve seen both struggles and successes with different wallet choices.

The Bitcoin ecosystem has matured since 2021 in El Salvador. Network connectivity varies across the country significantly. Government infrastructure creates unique opportunities and constraints for users.

This guide focuses on tools that function in real-world Salvadoran conditions. Theoretical solutions don’t always work practically here.

Wallets and Exchanges That Actually Work

The wallet landscape centers around one government-backed option and several independent alternatives. Each approach has distinct advantages depending on your priorities. Technical comfort level also matters for your choice.

Chivo wallet remains the official government option with unique benefits. The government’s $30 Bitcoin bonus program runs exclusively through Chivo. The wallet allows instant conversion between Bitcoin and US dollars with zero fees.

Chivo integration with local businesses is more comprehensive than alternatives. Merchants have been encouraged to accept it throughout San Salvador. This typically offers the smoothest payment experience at store counters.

However, Chivo has experienced security issues and technical glitches that concern cautious users. Being custodial means the government controls your private keys, not you. This contradicts Bitcoin’s fundamental “be your own bank” philosophy.

Muun Wallet stands out for most users seeking non-custodial alternatives. It supports both on-chain and Lightning Network transactions efficiently. You control your private keys completely, giving genuine ownership.

Phoenix Wallet works well for smaller, everyday transactions specifically. It focuses on Lightning Network payments for faster processing. The Lightning layer processes transactions cheaper than standard Bitcoin transfers.

More experienced users prioritizing maximum security should consider hardware wallets. Ledger or Trezor store private keys offline securely. They require more technical knowledge but provide the strongest protection available.

Wallet/Exchange Best For Key Advantage Main Drawback
Chivo Government bonus recipients and local transactions Free dollar conversion and $30 signup bonus Custodial control and technical reliability issues
Muun Wallet General users wanting security and ease Non-custodial with Lightning support Slightly higher fees than Lightning-only options
Phoenix Wallet Frequent small transactions Optimized for fast Lightning payments Limited on-chain transaction features
Strike Buying and selling Bitcoin in El Salvador Strong local presence and good liquidity Requires identity verification
Hardware Wallets Long-term Bitcoin storage Maximum security with offline storage Higher cost and learning curve

Strike has established the strongest exchange presence in El Salvador. Their Lightning Network integration makes transactions fast and affordable. Their liquidity is generally solid for the region.

International options like Kraken and Coinbase Pro offer more sophisticated trading features. They’re overkill if you just want basic buying and selling. They sometimes have withdrawal limitations or higher fees for smaller amounts.

Avoid sketchy local exchanges with no established track record. The cryptocurrency space attracts scammers unfortunately. Stick with recognized platforms that have operated for years.

Applications for Tracking and Management

Several applications help you monitor Bitcoin prices and track transaction status. These tools don’t hold your Bitcoin but provide valuable information. They offer functionality for managing your cryptocurrency portfolio.

Blockstream Green provides excellent transaction tracking for Bitcoin and Lightning Network payments. The clear transaction history and fee estimation features are helpful. This transparency matters when troubleshooting delayed payments.

The Coinbase app works well for price tracking specifically. Their clean price charts and customizable alerts notify you about price points. CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko offer similar functionality with more comprehensive data.

Mempool.space deserves special mention for anyone making regular Bitcoin transactions. This website shows current transaction fees and network congestion in real-time. Timing your transactions during low-fee periods can save significant money.

One essential “tool” isn’t digital at all: physical backup of your recovery phrases. Write down your wallet recovery words on paper securely. Keep copies in multiple secure physical locations for safety.

This isn’t like forgetting your bank password where customer service helps. With Bitcoin, you are the bank entirely. That responsibility shift catches many new users off guard unfortunately.

The tools you choose shape your entire Bitcoin experience significantly. Start with simpler options like Chivo or Muun first. Get comfortable with basic transactions, then gradually explore more advanced tools.

Answers to Common FAQs about El Salvador Bitcoin

Real people have real questions about using Bitcoin in El Salvador. Most deserve better answers than generic advice floating around. After tracking this experiment since President Nayib Bukele signed the Bitcoin Law, I’ve compiled questions that matter.

These questions help newcomers, tourists, and residents make practical decisions. The confusion is understandable. El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender.

This created a situation nobody had navigated before. Let me address the most common concerns with honest, experience-based answers.

How to Get Started with Bitcoin in El Salvador?

The starting point depends on whether you’re a resident or visitor. For Salvadoran citizens, the government-developed Chivo wallet provides the most straightforward entry.

Here’s the step-by-step process for residents:

  • Download the Chivo wallet app from the iOS App Store or Google Play Store
  • Complete registration using your DUI (government identification document)
  • Verify your identity through the app’s authentication process
  • Claim your $30 Bitcoin bonus provided by the government
  • Set up security features including PIN and biometric authentication

The interface is designed for Spanish-speaking beginners. You don’t need prior cryptocurrency experience. Once activated, you can receive Bitcoin from others, purchase more using US dollars, or spend it.

Visitors face a slightly different path since Chivo requires Salvadoran identification. International wallets like Muun, Phoenix, or Wallet of Satoshi work perfectly for tourists. Download your chosen wallet before arrival.

Secure your recovery phrase in a safe location. Either purchase Bitcoin beforehand or use one of El Salvador’s Bitcoin ATMs.

Many tourist-focused businesses accept Lightning Network payments. These include businesses in San Salvador, Bitcoin Beach, and other popular destinations. These transactions settle in seconds with minimal fees.

Is Bitcoin Safe for Transactions?

This question requires nuanced understanding. “Safe” means different things in different contexts. The Bitcoin network itself has never been successfully hacked in over 15 years.

That’s remarkable security by any standard. However, transaction safety depends heavily on user practices. Understanding the differences between Bitcoin and traditional payment systems matters.

Safety Aspect Bitcoin Characteristics Important Considerations
Network Security Extremely secure, cryptographically protected, decentralized verification The blockchain itself has never been compromised
Transaction Reversibility Irreversible once confirmed Sending to wrong address means permanent loss
User Responsibility Complete control means complete responsibility Lost passwords or stolen credentials have no recovery option
Fraud Protection No chargeback system Unlike credit cards, no institution reverses fraudulent transactions

Bitcoin transactions are “safe” regarding network security. They are “risky” in terms of user responsibility. If someone phishes your wallet credentials, they can drain your funds with zero recourse.

No customer service department will refund you. The key to safe Bitcoin use involves following basic security practices. Never share your recovery phrase.

Verify addresses before sending. Start with small test transactions. Use reputable wallet software.

What Are the Tax Implications of Using Bitcoin?

Under President Nayib Bukele’s Bitcoin Law, El Salvador exempts Bitcoin from capital gains taxes. If you purchase Bitcoin at $30,000 and later sell it at $50,000, that profit faces no taxation. This applies within El Salvador.

Businesses accepting Bitcoin must report these transactions for income tax purposes. The legal tender status means Bitcoin transactions receive the same accounting treatment. This matches any other payment method.

US citizens face a critical distinction. If you’re an American using Bitcoin in El Salvador, US tax law still applies. You owe capital gains taxes to the IRS on Bitcoin profits.

The IRS considers cryptocurrency property, not currency. This creates reporting obligations that Salvadoran tax exemptions don’t eliminate.

Can I Use Bitcoin Everywhere in El Salvador?

No, despite the legal tender designation. Many businesses don’t accept Bitcoin. This particularly affects smaller establishments without technological infrastructure.

The law technically requires acceptance if the business has the capability. However, enforcement remains inconsistent.

Acceptance varies dramatically by location. Major cities like San Salvador and tourist destinations have significantly better coverage. Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte offers the densest concentration of Bitcoin-accepting merchants.

Always carry US dollars as backup. The dollar remains more universally accepted. You’ll encounter situations where Bitcoin payment isn’t possible or practical.

What About Bitcoin Mining in El Salvador?

President Nayib Bukele made international headlines establishing government-operated bitcoin mining el salvador facilities. These are powered by geothermal energy from volcanoes. The “volcano energy” angle captures imagination while providing practical renewable power.

The scale remains relatively modest compared to mining operations in other countries. However, the concept demonstrates El Salvador’s commitment to the nayib bukele bitcoin vision. This goes beyond just payment adoption.

For individuals considering mining, the Bitcoin Law doesn’t prohibit it. However, residential electricity costs and equipment expenses make small-scale mining unprofitable. The upfront investment in specialized ASIC hardware runs into thousands of dollars.

Electricity consumption is substantial. Commercial bitcoin mining el salvador operations do exist and continue exploring expansion opportunities. The country’s renewable energy potential and favorable regulatory environment attract serious mining enterprises.

The government mining facilities process transactions using geothermal power. This comes from the Tecapa and San Miguel volcanoes. It’s both environmentally conscious and excellent marketing.

This positions El Salvador as an innovative leader in cryptocurrency adoption.

Reliable Sources for El Salvador Bitcoin News

Staying informed about el salvador crypto law requires filtering through noise to find credible information. I’ve spent considerable time identifying which sources deliver valuable insights versus those pushing agendas.

Tracking Bitcoin Developments Through Quality Media

Bitcoin Magazine provides the most comprehensive coverage of El Salvador’s Bitcoin adoption. Their on-the-ground reporting includes policy analysis and regular interviews. CoinDesk maintains dedicated coverage with balanced journalism covering both successes and challenges.

Reuters and Bloomberg offer international perspective on economic implications. Their coverage examines how financial institutions respond to El Salvador’s Bitcoin experiment.

Local newspapers like La Prensa Gráfica and El Diario de Hoy provide Spanish-language reporting. These sources cover daily life impacts and political debates.

Academic Research and Official Data

The National Bureau of Economic Research published a 2023 study examining actual adoption rates. The World Bank and International Monetary Fund release periodic assessments of fiscal implications related to el salvador crypto law.

Universidad Centroamericana José Simeón Cañas conducts regular public opinion polling on Bitcoin sentiment. The Central Reserve Bank of El Salvador publishes official economic statistics including Bitcoin-related data.

Cross-reference multiple sources before forming conclusions. Following economists like Steve Hanke, Bitcoin advocates like Max Keiser, and researchers like Aaron van Wirdum provides diverse perspectives. This approach helps separate reliable information from promotional content or unfounded criticism.

FAQ

How do I get started with Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Salvadoran residents should download the Chivo wallet app from iOS or Android. Complete registration using your government ID (DUI) and claim your Bitcoin bonus. The app guides you through wallet creation with a Spanish interface designed for beginners.You can receive Bitcoin from others, buy more with dollars, or spend at participating businesses. Visitors can use international wallets like Muun or Phoenix instead. Download the wallet, secure your recovery phrase, then buy Bitcoin before arrival or use local ATMs.Many tourist businesses in San Salvador and Bitcoin Beach accept Lightning Network payments. These transactions are faster and cheaper than standard Bitcoin transfers.

Is Bitcoin safe for transactions in El Salvador?

The Bitcoin network itself is extremely secure with no successful hacks in 15+ years. Transaction security depends more on how users protect their wallets. Sending Bitcoin to wrong addresses cannot be reversed.Phished wallet credentials let thieves steal funds with no way to recover them. Bitcoin transactions are safe regarding network security but risky due to user responsibility. The Chivo wallet offers some consumer protections through government backing.Non-custodial wallets place full responsibility on you to secure your funds.

What are the tax implications of using Bitcoin in El Salvador?

President Nayib Bukele’s Bitcoin Law exempts Bitcoin from capital gains taxes in El Salvador. Buying Bitcoin at ,000 and selling at ,000 means that ,000 profit isn’t taxed. Businesses accepting Bitcoin must report transactions for income tax purposes like dollar transactions.US citizens or residents using Bitcoin in El Salvador still face US tax law. You owe capital gains taxes to the IRS on Bitcoin profits regardless of el salvador crypto law. The 10% value-added tax still applies to goods and services purchased with Bitcoin.

Can I use Bitcoin everywhere in El Salvador?

No. Despite Bitcoin’s legal tender status, many businesses don’t accept it. Smaller establishments without technological infrastructure particularly avoid Bitcoin. The law technically requires acceptance if businesses have the technological capability.Enforcement remains inconsistent across the country. Major cities and tourist areas have better acceptance than rural regions. Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte has the highest concentration of Bitcoin-accepting businesses.Rural areas have minimal adoption. Always carry US dollars as backup since the dollar remains the primary currency.

What is Bitcoin Beach and why is it significant?

Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte started accepting Bitcoin in 2019, two years before the national el salvador bitcoin legal tender law. An anonymous Bitcoin donor funded this coastal town project. It became a showcase for Bitcoin adoption with restaurants, hostels, and shops operating on Bitcoin.Local residents received training in Bitcoin use. Tourism increased significantly, bringing economic benefits to the community. Bitcoin Beach represents ideal conditions with concentrated resources, targeted education, and a small community.These conditions don’t scale easily to a nation of 6.5 million people. It’s essentially a pilot project that informed the national rollout.

How does the Chivo wallet work?

The Chivo wallet is the government’s official state-backed Bitcoin wallet. It offers instant conversion between Bitcoin and dollars at no fee. The government’s 0 million trust fund backs these conversions.It integrates with the Bitcoin bonus program for citizens. The interface is designed for non-technical users, which helps with adoption. Chivo provides the most seamless experience for paying at businesses that accept Bitcoin in El Salvador.However, Chivo has experienced security issues and technical glitches. Being custodial means you don’t control your private keys—the government does. Many users prefer non-custodial alternatives like Muun Wallet for more control.

What about Bitcoin mining in El Salvador?

President Bukele established government-operated bitcoin mining el salvador facilities powered by geothermal energy from volcanoes. The “volcano energy” angle captures imagination with excellent marketing. The scale remains relatively small compared to mining operations in the United States or Kazakhstan.El Salvador’s Bitcoin Law doesn’t prohibit individual mining. Residential electricity costs and equipment expenses make small-scale mining unprofitable for most people. Commercial mining operations exist and are exploring expansion.They’re attracted by renewable energy potential and a favorable regulatory environment.

What is Bitcoin City and when will it be built?

El Salvador Bitcoin City is a planned city announced in November 2021. It would be built in the eastern region of La Unión. The city would be powered entirely by geothermal energy from the nearby Conchagua volcano.The vision includes residential areas, commercial zones, and massive Bitcoin mining operations. It would have zero income, property, or capital gains taxes—only a 10% value-added tax. As of 2024, Bitcoin City remains largely conceptual.Some preliminary infrastructure work has begun, but nothing resembles an actual city. Funding challenges, market volatility, and economic questions have hampered the project. It’s tied to the Volcano Bonds initiative, which also hasn’t materialized as originally planned.

How much Bitcoin does El Salvador own?

Salvadoran bitcoin reserves are tracked through President Bukele’s occasional Twitter/X announcements. The government doesn’t release comprehensive regular reports. Based on available information, El Salvador has purchased Bitcoin in incremental amounts.Holdings are estimated around 2,700-5,800 BTC as of late 2024. Exact numbers vary depending on sources. The government buys during dips as part of a dollar-cost averaging strategy.These holdings have experienced significant value swings. They’re worth considerably more during bull markets but lost tens of millions during the 2022 crash. This raises concerns about fiscal responsibility and taxpayer money at risk through cryptocurrency volatility.

What happened to the Bitcoin Bond (Volcano Bond)?

The Bitcoin Bond initiative, officially called “Volcano Bonds,” was announced in November 2021. It was designed as a How do I get started with Bitcoin in El Salvador?Salvadoran residents should download the Chivo wallet app from iOS or Android. Complete registration using your government ID (DUI) and claim your Bitcoin bonus. The app guides you through wallet creation with a Spanish interface designed for beginners.You can receive Bitcoin from others, buy more with dollars, or spend at participating businesses. Visitors can use international wallets like Muun or Phoenix instead. Download the wallet, secure your recovery phrase, then buy Bitcoin before arrival or use local ATMs.Many tourist businesses in San Salvador and Bitcoin Beach accept Lightning Network payments. These transactions are faster and cheaper than standard Bitcoin transfers.Is Bitcoin safe for transactions in El Salvador?The Bitcoin network itself is extremely secure with no successful hacks in 15+ years. Transaction security depends more on how users protect their wallets. Sending Bitcoin to wrong addresses cannot be reversed.Phished wallet credentials let thieves steal funds with no way to recover them. Bitcoin transactions are safe regarding network security but risky due to user responsibility. The Chivo wallet offers some consumer protections through government backing.Non-custodial wallets place full responsibility on you to secure your funds.What are the tax implications of using Bitcoin in El Salvador?President Nayib Bukele’s Bitcoin Law exempts Bitcoin from capital gains taxes in El Salvador. Buying Bitcoin at ,000 and selling at ,000 means that ,000 profit isn’t taxed. Businesses accepting Bitcoin must report transactions for income tax purposes like dollar transactions.US citizens or residents using Bitcoin in El Salvador still face US tax law. You owe capital gains taxes to the IRS on Bitcoin profits regardless of el salvador crypto law. The 10% value-added tax still applies to goods and services purchased with Bitcoin.Can I use Bitcoin everywhere in El Salvador?No. Despite Bitcoin’s legal tender status, many businesses don’t accept it. Smaller establishments without technological infrastructure particularly avoid Bitcoin. The law technically requires acceptance if businesses have the technological capability.Enforcement remains inconsistent across the country. Major cities and tourist areas have better acceptance than rural regions. Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte has the highest concentration of Bitcoin-accepting businesses.Rural areas have minimal adoption. Always carry US dollars as backup since the dollar remains the primary currency.What is Bitcoin Beach and why is it significant?Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte started accepting Bitcoin in 2019, two years before the national el salvador bitcoin legal tender law. An anonymous Bitcoin donor funded this coastal town project. It became a showcase for Bitcoin adoption with restaurants, hostels, and shops operating on Bitcoin.Local residents received training in Bitcoin use. Tourism increased significantly, bringing economic benefits to the community. Bitcoin Beach represents ideal conditions with concentrated resources, targeted education, and a small community.These conditions don’t scale easily to a nation of 6.5 million people. It’s essentially a pilot project that informed the national rollout.How does the Chivo wallet work?The Chivo wallet is the government’s official state-backed Bitcoin wallet. It offers instant conversion between Bitcoin and dollars at no fee. The government’s 0 million trust fund backs these conversions.It integrates with the Bitcoin bonus program for citizens. The interface is designed for non-technical users, which helps with adoption. Chivo provides the most seamless experience for paying at businesses that accept Bitcoin in El Salvador.However, Chivo has experienced security issues and technical glitches. Being custodial means you don’t control your private keys—the government does. Many users prefer non-custodial alternatives like Muun Wallet for more control.What about Bitcoin mining in El Salvador?President Bukele established government-operated bitcoin mining el salvador facilities powered by geothermal energy from volcanoes. The “volcano energy” angle captures imagination with excellent marketing. The scale remains relatively small compared to mining operations in the United States or Kazakhstan.El Salvador’s Bitcoin Law doesn’t prohibit individual mining. Residential electricity costs and equipment expenses make small-scale mining unprofitable for most people. Commercial mining operations exist and are exploring expansion.They’re attracted by renewable energy potential and a favorable regulatory environment.What is Bitcoin City and when will it be built?El Salvador Bitcoin City is a planned city announced in November 2021. It would be built in the eastern region of La Unión. The city would be powered entirely by geothermal energy from the nearby Conchagua volcano.The vision includes residential areas, commercial zones, and massive Bitcoin mining operations. It would have zero income, property, or capital gains taxes—only a 10% value-added tax. As of 2024, Bitcoin City remains largely conceptual.Some preliminary infrastructure work has begun, but nothing resembles an actual city. Funding challenges, market volatility, and economic questions have hampered the project. It’s tied to the Volcano Bonds initiative, which also hasn’t materialized as originally planned.How much Bitcoin does El Salvador own?Salvadoran bitcoin reserves are tracked through President Bukele’s occasional Twitter/X announcements. The government doesn’t release comprehensive regular reports. Based on available information, El Salvador has purchased Bitcoin in incremental amounts.Holdings are estimated around 2,700-5,800 BTC as of late 2024. Exact numbers vary depending on sources. The government buys during dips as part of a dollar-cost averaging strategy.These holdings have experienced significant value swings. They’re worth considerably more during bull markets but lost tens of millions during the 2022 crash. This raises concerns about fiscal responsibility and taxpayer money at risk through cryptocurrency volatility.What happened to the Bitcoin Bond (Volcano Bond)?The Bitcoin Bond initiative, officially called “Volcano Bonds,” was announced in November 2021. It was designed as a

FAQ

How do I get started with Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Salvadoran residents should download the Chivo wallet app from iOS or Android. Complete registration using your government ID (DUI) and claim your Bitcoin bonus. The app guides you through wallet creation with a Spanish interface designed for beginners.

You can receive Bitcoin from others, buy more with dollars, or spend at participating businesses. Visitors can use international wallets like Muun or Phoenix instead. Download the wallet, secure your recovery phrase, then buy Bitcoin before arrival or use local ATMs.

Many tourist businesses in San Salvador and Bitcoin Beach accept Lightning Network payments. These transactions are faster and cheaper than standard Bitcoin transfers.

Is Bitcoin safe for transactions in El Salvador?

The Bitcoin network itself is extremely secure with no successful hacks in 15+ years. Transaction security depends more on how users protect their wallets. Sending Bitcoin to wrong addresses cannot be reversed.

Phished wallet credentials let thieves steal funds with no way to recover them. Bitcoin transactions are safe regarding network security but risky due to user responsibility. The Chivo wallet offers some consumer protections through government backing.

Non-custodial wallets place full responsibility on you to secure your funds.

What are the tax implications of using Bitcoin in El Salvador?

President Nayib Bukele’s Bitcoin Law exempts Bitcoin from capital gains taxes in El Salvador. Buying Bitcoin at ,000 and selling at ,000 means that ,000 profit isn’t taxed. Businesses accepting Bitcoin must report transactions for income tax purposes like dollar transactions.

US citizens or residents using Bitcoin in El Salvador still face US tax law. You owe capital gains taxes to the IRS on Bitcoin profits regardless of el salvador crypto law. The 10% value-added tax still applies to goods and services purchased with Bitcoin.

Can I use Bitcoin everywhere in El Salvador?

No. Despite Bitcoin’s legal tender status, many businesses don’t accept it. Smaller establishments without technological infrastructure particularly avoid Bitcoin. The law technically requires acceptance if businesses have the technological capability.

Enforcement remains inconsistent across the country. Major cities and tourist areas have better acceptance than rural regions. Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte has the highest concentration of Bitcoin-accepting businesses.

Rural areas have minimal adoption. Always carry US dollars as backup since the dollar remains the primary currency.

What is Bitcoin Beach and why is it significant?

Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte started accepting Bitcoin in 2019, two years before the national el salvador bitcoin legal tender law. An anonymous Bitcoin donor funded this coastal town project. It became a showcase for Bitcoin adoption with restaurants, hostels, and shops operating on Bitcoin.

Local residents received training in Bitcoin use. Tourism increased significantly, bringing economic benefits to the community. Bitcoin Beach represents ideal conditions with concentrated resources, targeted education, and a small community.

These conditions don’t scale easily to a nation of 6.5 million people. It’s essentially a pilot project that informed the national rollout.

How does the Chivo wallet work?

The Chivo wallet is the government’s official state-backed Bitcoin wallet. It offers instant conversion between Bitcoin and dollars at no fee. The government’s 0 million trust fund backs these conversions.

It integrates with the Bitcoin bonus program for citizens. The interface is designed for non-technical users, which helps with adoption. Chivo provides the most seamless experience for paying at businesses that accept Bitcoin in El Salvador.

However, Chivo has experienced security issues and technical glitches. Being custodial means you don’t control your private keys—the government does. Many users prefer non-custodial alternatives like Muun Wallet for more control.

What about Bitcoin mining in El Salvador?

President Bukele established government-operated bitcoin mining el salvador facilities powered by geothermal energy from volcanoes. The “volcano energy” angle captures imagination with excellent marketing. The scale remains relatively small compared to mining operations in the United States or Kazakhstan.

El Salvador’s Bitcoin Law doesn’t prohibit individual mining. Residential electricity costs and equipment expenses make small-scale mining unprofitable for most people. Commercial mining operations exist and are exploring expansion.

They’re attracted by renewable energy potential and a favorable regulatory environment.

What is Bitcoin City and when will it be built?

El Salvador Bitcoin City is a planned city announced in November 2021. It would be built in the eastern region of La Unión. The city would be powered entirely by geothermal energy from the nearby Conchagua volcano.

The vision includes residential areas, commercial zones, and massive Bitcoin mining operations. It would have zero income, property, or capital gains taxes—only a 10% value-added tax. As of 2024, Bitcoin City remains largely conceptual.

Some preliminary infrastructure work has begun, but nothing resembles an actual city. Funding challenges, market volatility, and economic questions have hampered the project. It’s tied to the Volcano Bonds initiative, which also hasn’t materialized as originally planned.

How much Bitcoin does El Salvador own?

Salvadoran bitcoin reserves are tracked through President Bukele’s occasional Twitter/X announcements. The government doesn’t release comprehensive regular reports. Based on available information, El Salvador has purchased Bitcoin in incremental amounts.

Holdings are estimated around 2,700-5,800 BTC as of late 2024. Exact numbers vary depending on sources. The government buys during dips as part of a dollar-cost averaging strategy.

These holdings have experienced significant value swings. They’re worth considerably more during bull markets but lost tens of millions during the 2022 crash. This raises concerns about fiscal responsibility and taxpayer money at risk through cryptocurrency volatility.

What happened to the Bitcoin Bond (Volcano Bond)?

The Bitcoin Bond initiative, officially called “Volcano Bonds,” was announced in November 2021. It was designed as a

FAQ

How do I get started with Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Salvadoran residents should download the Chivo wallet app from iOS or Android. Complete registration using your government ID (DUI) and claim your $30 Bitcoin bonus. The app guides you through wallet creation with a Spanish interface designed for beginners.

You can receive Bitcoin from others, buy more with dollars, or spend at participating businesses. Visitors can use international wallets like Muun or Phoenix instead. Download the wallet, secure your recovery phrase, then buy Bitcoin before arrival or use local ATMs.

Many tourist businesses in San Salvador and Bitcoin Beach accept Lightning Network payments. These transactions are faster and cheaper than standard Bitcoin transfers.

Is Bitcoin safe for transactions in El Salvador?

The Bitcoin network itself is extremely secure with no successful hacks in 15+ years. Transaction security depends more on how users protect their wallets. Sending Bitcoin to wrong addresses cannot be reversed.

Phished wallet credentials let thieves steal funds with no way to recover them. Bitcoin transactions are safe regarding network security but risky due to user responsibility. The Chivo wallet offers some consumer protections through government backing.

Non-custodial wallets place full responsibility on you to secure your funds.

What are the tax implications of using Bitcoin in El Salvador?

President Nayib Bukele’s Bitcoin Law exempts Bitcoin from capital gains taxes in El Salvador. Buying Bitcoin at $30,000 and selling at $50,000 means that $20,000 profit isn’t taxed. Businesses accepting Bitcoin must report transactions for income tax purposes like dollar transactions.

US citizens or residents using Bitcoin in El Salvador still face US tax law. You owe capital gains taxes to the IRS on Bitcoin profits regardless of el salvador crypto law. The 10% value-added tax still applies to goods and services purchased with Bitcoin.

Can I use Bitcoin everywhere in El Salvador?

No. Despite Bitcoin’s legal tender status, many businesses don’t accept it. Smaller establishments without technological infrastructure particularly avoid Bitcoin. The law technically requires acceptance if businesses have the technological capability.

Enforcement remains inconsistent across the country. Major cities and tourist areas have better acceptance than rural regions. Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte has the highest concentration of Bitcoin-accepting businesses.

Rural areas have minimal adoption. Always carry US dollars as backup since the dollar remains the primary currency.

What is Bitcoin Beach and why is it significant?

Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte started accepting Bitcoin in 2019, two years before the national el salvador bitcoin legal tender law. An anonymous Bitcoin donor funded this coastal town project. It became a showcase for Bitcoin adoption with restaurants, hostels, and shops operating on Bitcoin.

Local residents received training in Bitcoin use. Tourism increased significantly, bringing economic benefits to the community. Bitcoin Beach represents ideal conditions with concentrated resources, targeted education, and a small community.

These conditions don’t scale easily to a nation of 6.5 million people. It’s essentially a pilot project that informed the national rollout.

How does the Chivo wallet work?

The Chivo wallet is the government’s official state-backed Bitcoin wallet. It offers instant conversion between Bitcoin and dollars at no fee. The government’s $150 million trust fund backs these conversions.

It integrates with the $30 Bitcoin bonus program for citizens. The interface is designed for non-technical users, which helps with adoption. Chivo provides the most seamless experience for paying at businesses that accept Bitcoin in El Salvador.

However, Chivo has experienced security issues and technical glitches. Being custodial means you don’t control your private keys—the government does. Many users prefer non-custodial alternatives like Muun Wallet for more control.

What about Bitcoin mining in El Salvador?

President Bukele established government-operated bitcoin mining el salvador facilities powered by geothermal energy from volcanoes. The “volcano energy” angle captures imagination with excellent marketing. The scale remains relatively small compared to mining operations in the United States or Kazakhstan.

El Salvador’s Bitcoin Law doesn’t prohibit individual mining. Residential electricity costs and equipment expenses make small-scale mining unprofitable for most people. Commercial mining operations exist and are exploring expansion.

They’re attracted by renewable energy potential and a favorable regulatory environment.

What is Bitcoin City and when will it be built?

El Salvador Bitcoin City is a planned city announced in November 2021. It would be built in the eastern region of La Unión. The city would be powered entirely by geothermal energy from the nearby Conchagua volcano.

The vision includes residential areas, commercial zones, and massive Bitcoin mining operations. It would have zero income, property, or capital gains taxes—only a 10% value-added tax. As of 2024, Bitcoin City remains largely conceptual.

Some preliminary infrastructure work has begun, but nothing resembles an actual city. Funding challenges, market volatility, and economic questions have hampered the project. It’s tied to the Volcano Bonds initiative, which also hasn’t materialized as originally planned.

How much Bitcoin does El Salvador own?

Salvadoran bitcoin reserves are tracked through President Bukele’s occasional Twitter/X announcements. The government doesn’t release comprehensive regular reports. Based on available information, El Salvador has purchased Bitcoin in incremental amounts.

Holdings are estimated around 2,700-5,800 BTC as of late 2024. Exact numbers vary depending on sources. The government buys during dips as part of a dollar-cost averaging strategy.

These holdings have experienced significant value swings. They’re worth considerably more during bull markets but lost tens of millions during the 2022 crash. This raises concerns about fiscal responsibility and taxpayer money at risk through cryptocurrency volatility.

What happened to the Bitcoin Bond (Volcano Bond)?

The Bitcoin Bond initiative, officially called “Volcano Bonds,” was announced in November 2021. It was designed as a $1 billion fundraising mechanism. The plan was to use half the proceeds to buy more Bitcoin.

The other half would build energy and mining infrastructure. Investors would get returns from both Bitcoin appreciation and geothermal energy profits. The bonds were supposed to launch in 2022.

They’ve been repeatedly delayed due to market conditions, regulatory concerns, and investor skepticism. As of late 2024, the bonds still haven’t materialized in their original form. The government continues negotiating with potential investors and has discussed modified versions with different structures.

How has el salvador bitcoin adoption affected remittances?

Bitcoin adoption in el salvador has had its most measurable positive impact on remittances. Traditional services like Western Union charge 7-10% in fees plus unfavorable exchange rates. Bitcoin transactions reduce these costs to under 2% in most cases.

Remittances represent about 24% of GDP in El Salvador. Calculations suggest Salvadoran families collectively save $400+ million annually through reduced remittance fees. This represents real money staying in families’ pockets instead of going to intermediaries.

However, actual Bitcoin usage for remittances remains limited to maybe 10-15% of total remittance volume. Most people still use traditional services due to familiarity and ease of use.

What do Salvadorans actually think about Bitcoin?

Public sentiment is complex and divided. Universidad Centroamericana’s 2023 polling showed approximately 12% of Salvadorans actively use Bitcoin regularly. Another 20% have used it occasionally.

Only 35% viewed bitcoin adoption in el salvador positively. About 45% expressed skepticism or opposition. Sentiment correlates strongly with age and location.

Younger urban Salvadorans (18-35) show 48% favorability toward Bitcoin. Rural residents over 50 show only 18% favorability. Many people downloaded Chivo wallet for the free $30 but stopped using it after spending that bonus.

Can tourists use Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Yes, tourists can definitely use Bitcoin in El Salvador. Many businesses in tourist areas specifically welcome it. Major cities like San Salvador and tourist destinations like Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte have the highest concentration.

You’ll need a Bitcoin wallet app like Muun or Phoenix. Lightning Network support helps with faster, cheaper transactions. Many hotels, restaurants, and tour operators in tourist zones accept Bitcoin.

However, don’t rely exclusively on Bitcoin. Acceptance outside major tourist areas is limited. You’ll need US dollars for most transactions, though Bitcoin ATMs are available in cities.

What are the biggest challenges facing Bitcoin in El Salvador?

The biggest challenge is volatility. Bitcoin’s price swings make it problematic for everyday transactions. People need price stability for groceries and rent.

Technical infrastructure creates daily friction too. Internet penetration sits around 60%. Power outages are common in rural areas, and the Chivo wallet has experienced technical glitches.

Smartphone ownership and digital literacy present additional barriers. Many rural residents cannot access or understand the technology. Survey data shows 75% of Salvadorans who tried Bitcoin cited volatility as their primary concern. The learning curve is steeper than the government initially anticipated.

How does Nayib Bukele’s bitcoin strategy fit into his broader political agenda?

Nayib Bukele bitcoin policy is part of his broader brand as a disruptive, tech-forward leader. He’s willing to challenge international financial institutions and traditional economic orthodoxy. The Bitcoin adoption generated massive international attention.

It positioned El Salvador and Bukele personally at the center of the cryptocurrency movement. It appeals to his young, urban supporter base while signaling independence from institutions like the IMF. Critics argue it’s more about building his personal brand and international profile than sound economic policy.

Supporters see it as genuine innovation that could provide financial sovereignty. Either way, Bitcoin has become inseparable from Bukele’s political identity.

billion fundraising mechanism. The plan was to use half the proceeds to buy more Bitcoin.

The other half would build energy and mining infrastructure. Investors would get returns from both Bitcoin appreciation and geothermal energy profits. The bonds were supposed to launch in 2022.

They’ve been repeatedly delayed due to market conditions, regulatory concerns, and investor skepticism. As of late 2024, the bonds still haven’t materialized in their original form. The government continues negotiating with potential investors and has discussed modified versions with different structures.

How has el salvador bitcoin adoption affected remittances?

Bitcoin adoption in el salvador has had its most measurable positive impact on remittances. Traditional services like Western Union charge 7-10% in fees plus unfavorable exchange rates. Bitcoin transactions reduce these costs to under 2% in most cases.

Remittances represent about 24% of GDP in El Salvador. Calculations suggest Salvadoran families collectively save 0+ million annually through reduced remittance fees. This represents real money staying in families’ pockets instead of going to intermediaries.

However, actual Bitcoin usage for remittances remains limited to maybe 10-15% of total remittance volume. Most people still use traditional services due to familiarity and ease of use.

What do Salvadorans actually think about Bitcoin?

Public sentiment is complex and divided. Universidad Centroamericana’s 2023 polling showed approximately 12% of Salvadorans actively use Bitcoin regularly. Another 20% have used it occasionally.

Only 35% viewed bitcoin adoption in el salvador positively. About 45% expressed skepticism or opposition. Sentiment correlates strongly with age and location.

Younger urban Salvadorans (18-35) show 48% favorability toward Bitcoin. Rural residents over 50 show only 18% favorability. Many people downloaded Chivo wallet for the free but stopped using it after spending that bonus.

Can tourists use Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Yes, tourists can definitely use Bitcoin in El Salvador. Many businesses in tourist areas specifically welcome it. Major cities like San Salvador and tourist destinations like Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte have the highest concentration.

You’ll need a Bitcoin wallet app like Muun or Phoenix. Lightning Network support helps with faster, cheaper transactions. Many hotels, restaurants, and tour operators in tourist zones accept Bitcoin.

However, don’t rely exclusively on Bitcoin. Acceptance outside major tourist areas is limited. You’ll need US dollars for most transactions, though Bitcoin ATMs are available in cities.

What are the biggest challenges facing Bitcoin in El Salvador?

The biggest challenge is volatility. Bitcoin’s price swings make it problematic for everyday transactions. People need price stability for groceries and rent.

Technical infrastructure creates daily friction too. Internet penetration sits around 60%. Power outages are common in rural areas, and the Chivo wallet has experienced technical glitches.

Smartphone ownership and digital literacy present additional barriers. Many rural residents cannot access or understand the technology. Survey data shows 75% of Salvadorans who tried Bitcoin cited volatility as their primary concern. The learning curve is steeper than the government initially anticipated.

How does Nayib Bukele’s bitcoin strategy fit into his broader political agenda?

Nayib Bukele bitcoin policy is part of his broader brand as a disruptive, tech-forward leader. He’s willing to challenge international financial institutions and traditional economic orthodoxy. The Bitcoin adoption generated massive international attention.

It positioned El Salvador and Bukele personally at the center of the cryptocurrency movement. It appeals to his young, urban supporter base while signaling independence from institutions like the IMF. Critics argue it’s more about building his personal brand and international profile than sound economic policy.

Supporters see it as genuine innovation that could provide financial sovereignty. Either way, Bitcoin has become inseparable from Bukele’s political identity.

billion fundraising mechanism. The plan was to use half the proceeds to buy more Bitcoin.The other half would build energy and mining infrastructure. Investors would get returns from both Bitcoin appreciation and geothermal energy profits. The bonds were supposed to launch in 2022.They’ve been repeatedly delayed due to market conditions, regulatory concerns, and investor skepticism. As of late 2024, the bonds still haven’t materialized in their original form. The government continues negotiating with potential investors and has discussed modified versions with different structures.How has el salvador bitcoin adoption affected remittances?Bitcoin adoption in el salvador has had its most measurable positive impact on remittances. Traditional services like Western Union charge 7-10% in fees plus unfavorable exchange rates. Bitcoin transactions reduce these costs to under 2% in most cases.Remittances represent about 24% of GDP in El Salvador. Calculations suggest Salvadoran families collectively save 0+ million annually through reduced remittance fees. This represents real money staying in families’ pockets instead of going to intermediaries.However, actual Bitcoin usage for remittances remains limited to maybe 10-15% of total remittance volume. Most people still use traditional services due to familiarity and ease of use.What do Salvadorans actually think about Bitcoin?Public sentiment is complex and divided. Universidad Centroamericana’s 2023 polling showed approximately 12% of Salvadorans actively use Bitcoin regularly. Another 20% have used it occasionally.Only 35% viewed bitcoin adoption in el salvador positively. About 45% expressed skepticism or opposition. Sentiment correlates strongly with age and location.Younger urban Salvadorans (18-35) show 48% favorability toward Bitcoin. Rural residents over 50 show only 18% favorability. Many people downloaded Chivo wallet for the free but stopped using it after spending that bonus.Can tourists use Bitcoin in El Salvador?Yes, tourists can definitely use Bitcoin in El Salvador. Many businesses in tourist areas specifically welcome it. Major cities like San Salvador and tourist destinations like Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte have the highest concentration.You’ll need a Bitcoin wallet app like Muun or Phoenix. Lightning Network support helps with faster, cheaper transactions. Many hotels, restaurants, and tour operators in tourist zones accept Bitcoin.However, don’t rely exclusively on Bitcoin. Acceptance outside major tourist areas is limited. You’ll need US dollars for most transactions, though Bitcoin ATMs are available in cities.What are the biggest challenges facing Bitcoin in El Salvador?The biggest challenge is volatility. Bitcoin’s price swings make it problematic for everyday transactions. People need price stability for groceries and rent.Technical infrastructure creates daily friction too. Internet penetration sits around 60%. Power outages are common in rural areas, and the Chivo wallet has experienced technical glitches.Smartphone ownership and digital literacy present additional barriers. Many rural residents cannot access or understand the technology. Survey data shows 75% of Salvadorans who tried Bitcoin cited volatility as their primary concern. The learning curve is steeper than the government initially anticipated.How does Nayib Bukele’s bitcoin strategy fit into his broader political agenda?Nayib Bukele bitcoin policy is part of his broader brand as a disruptive, tech-forward leader. He’s willing to challenge international financial institutions and traditional economic orthodoxy. The Bitcoin adoption generated massive international attention.It positioned El Salvador and Bukele personally at the center of the cryptocurrency movement. It appeals to his young, urban supporter base while signaling independence from institutions like the IMF. Critics argue it’s more about building his personal brand and international profile than sound economic policy.Supporters see it as genuine innovation that could provide financial sovereignty. Either way, Bitcoin has become inseparable from Bukele’s political identity. billion fundraising mechanism. The plan was to use half the proceeds to buy more Bitcoin.The other half would build energy and mining infrastructure. Investors would get returns from both Bitcoin appreciation and geothermal energy profits. The bonds were supposed to launch in 2022.They’ve been repeatedly delayed due to market conditions, regulatory concerns, and investor skepticism. As of late 2024, the bonds still haven’t materialized in their original form. The government continues negotiating with potential investors and has discussed modified versions with different structures.

How has el salvador bitcoin adoption affected remittances?

Bitcoin adoption in el salvador has had its most measurable positive impact on remittances. Traditional services like Western Union charge 7-10% in fees plus unfavorable exchange rates. Bitcoin transactions reduce these costs to under 2% in most cases.Remittances represent about 24% of GDP in El Salvador. Calculations suggest Salvadoran families collectively save 0+ million annually through reduced remittance fees. This represents real money staying in families’ pockets instead of going to intermediaries.However, actual Bitcoin usage for remittances remains limited to maybe 10-15% of total remittance volume. Most people still use traditional services due to familiarity and ease of use.

What do Salvadorans actually think about Bitcoin?

Public sentiment is complex and divided. Universidad Centroamericana’s 2023 polling showed approximately 12% of Salvadorans actively use Bitcoin regularly. Another 20% have used it occasionally.Only 35% viewed bitcoin adoption in el salvador positively. About 45% expressed skepticism or opposition. Sentiment correlates strongly with age and location.Younger urban Salvadorans (18-35) show 48% favorability toward Bitcoin. Rural residents over 50 show only 18% favorability. Many people downloaded Chivo wallet for the free but stopped using it after spending that bonus.

Can tourists use Bitcoin in El Salvador?

Yes, tourists can definitely use Bitcoin in El Salvador. Many businesses in tourist areas specifically welcome it. Major cities like San Salvador and tourist destinations like Bitcoin Beach in El Zonte have the highest concentration.You’ll need a Bitcoin wallet app like Muun or Phoenix. Lightning Network support helps with faster, cheaper transactions. Many hotels, restaurants, and tour operators in tourist zones accept Bitcoin.However, don’t rely exclusively on Bitcoin. Acceptance outside major tourist areas is limited. You’ll need US dollars for most transactions, though Bitcoin ATMs are available in cities.

What are the biggest challenges facing Bitcoin in El Salvador?

The biggest challenge is volatility. Bitcoin’s price swings make it problematic for everyday transactions. People need price stability for groceries and rent.Technical infrastructure creates daily friction too. Internet penetration sits around 60%. Power outages are common in rural areas, and the Chivo wallet has experienced technical glitches.Smartphone ownership and digital literacy present additional barriers. Many rural residents cannot access or understand the technology. Survey data shows 75% of Salvadorans who tried Bitcoin cited volatility as their primary concern. The learning curve is steeper than the government initially anticipated.

How does Nayib Bukele’s bitcoin strategy fit into his broader political agenda?

Nayib Bukele bitcoin policy is part of his broader brand as a disruptive, tech-forward leader. He’s willing to challenge international financial institutions and traditional economic orthodoxy. The Bitcoin adoption generated massive international attention.It positioned El Salvador and Bukele personally at the center of the cryptocurrency movement. It appeals to his young, urban supporter base while signaling independence from institutions like the IMF. Critics argue it’s more about building his personal brand and international profile than sound economic policy.Supporters see it as genuine innovation that could provide financial sovereignty. Either way, Bitcoin has become inseparable from Bukele’s political identity.
Author Francis Merced